Thawfest : How it should have happened

I did not like how the episode 'Thawfest' from Riders of Berk ended. Personally, I felt that Astrid and the others were too harsh on Hiccup being a 'lousy winner', resulting in Hiccup letting Snotlout win. Here is my attempt at a more pro-Hiccup plot, where he's not hated for getting back at Snotlout after the years of grief he gave Hiccup.