Third Time's The Charm

26 years of hunting and surviving after Sam and Bobby disappeared through the portal and Benny was still doing what he did best. Humans have a way of finding him though, even in monster heaven. It's a race to escape Purgatory and try to find a place on Earth again, but there are loose ends out there- leaving won't be easy. Purgatory fic with Benny and an OFC, give it a shot!