Carlisle Is Lying

There are many ways to describe Carlisle Cullen, To some, he is the uncanny, good-looking man that is just too pale and quiet to be liked comfortably. To his family, he is generally a good-natured man who tries to pick the most reasonable and well-meaning choice. Liar hasn't been one of the ways to describe Carlisle, but should it? (Crosses over with Life and Death)