Oneshot set during the second season. After a long case, the team try to relax and take their mind off the events they have suffered through, yet all Aaron can do is focus on one person. Someone who is acting differently and still recovering from her shooting, the mental scars no one had cared to ask about torturing her. Elle has built her walls, but Aaron wants to bring them down.

What would have happened if it had been Nancy who had discovered Giselle that night instead of Robert? Shocked at the strange women, yet willing to take her in, Nancy tries to help Giselle get through life in New York. It doesn't go smoothly. But with friendship blossoming between the two, will something else swiftly follow?