Sequel to "Psychic in the City" - In New York, Peter and Gus try to track down Neal and Shawn. In California, Shawn and Neal escape from Ridley. Back at Santa Barbara, the team becomes suspicious of Ridley's true motives.

1995, Chicago: Shawn Spencer meets Neal Caffrey 2005, New York: Shawn Spencer is hired by the FBI to help catch an international thief and con-man 2013, New York: Shawn Spencer is back in New York and it's all fun and games until someone gets framed for stealing a priceless piece of art.