There was nothing like taking an old friend in; especially when they needed help. However, Sam and Dean get more than they bargained for when that friend wants to return to the hunting life. Dean is distraught and Sam is sympathetic. Will the Winchester's be able to convince them to go back to their old life, or will their attempts at convincing fall flat?

With an alcoholic brother and a depressed mother, Jodie Westfield already had a lot on her plate, but her brother had went along and snagged someone who would change everything, for every one of them, all because of a silly little bet.