On the hunt for Ben Church, Haytham was presented with countless opportunities to kill the Templars' greatest threat, Connor. So why hadn't he? His mistake would be his ruin, and he once again finds himself with no other choice but to ally with the Assassin, this time against those he once called brothers, including the now tyrannical Charles Lee. *Eventual HaythCon*

Shay has dedicated his life to the Templar cause; however, the past can't be erased. The Brotherhood will stop at nothing to exact their vengeance and reclaim what was taken from them. Shay's guilt and newly-awoken affections are only complicating the situation further. *Eventual Shaytham*

In which Abraham reflects on his past relationship with Ichabod Crane. Ichabod/Abraham (Ichabroham) *yaoi and smut warning*

Moloch has a new purpose for Katrina, but in taking her from Abraham, he has broken their pact. With no other options, Death will side with the biblical Witnesses for a final act of revenge.

Shay has returned to Sleepy Hollow to investigate the disappearance of several recruits and fight the headless terror that lurks here. During this, he runs into a familiar enemy and is forced to ally with him against the menace.