"Part of her still felt like the words seemed almost sickeningly romantic for her… because when had Spencer Hastings ever believed in fairytales?" Spencer and Toby. Inspired by the events of 5x12. Oneshot.
"She felt her throat tighten as she remembered her boyfriend's tears earlier that day. It had been the most prominent thing on her mind ever since, always lingering in the back of her already overworked brain while Aria and Hanna rambled on about things that suddenly seemed much more futile." Post 4x02. Oneshot.
"But only recently did he feel like he'd finally managed to fully zone out on the devastating reality he was stuck in." Prequel to A Beautiful Mind. Oneshot.
"She saw an open suitcase – not an overly big one but packed to the brim all the same – and it hit her like a blow to the head because somehow she had managed to forget he was leaving for a job in Guilford later today." Spencer and Toby. Season 5. Oneshot.
"How and when had it become such a heart-wrenching dilemma to have to choose between being true to her and being true to himself?" Post 5x17. Spencer and Toby. Oneshot.
"She entered the ruin of a house a little wearily, her eyes instinctively looking around for Toby amidst a landscape of black residue." Spencer and Toby. Continuation of 5x06. Oneshot.
"The girl took a step away from the tree, wiping her face with her hands and straightening out her blue and white striped dress, and Toby did a double take when recognition settled into him." First impressions. Spencer and Toby. Oneshot.
"He had the ability to shred her to pieces in a single evening, and the mere idea of that was scary as hell; but he also had the ability, and more importantly, the patience, to put her back together." A series of random events trigger Spencer and Toby into dealing with the more painful occurrences of their tumultuous history.
"It really wasn't fair how winning no longer held quite the same brilliance, but the sting of losing had yet to lose its edge." Two tennis matches. Two different outcomes. One cameo appearance by someone associated with the sport. Spencer and Toby. Oneshot.
"'How much do you know of what happened to your mom when she was young' Emily finally asked, and Aaron just shrugged." Sequel to A Beautiful Mind. Oneshot.
"He would never forget the day he first laid eyes on Spencer Hastings." Spencer and Toby. The college years, through the eyes of someone unlikely. Oneshot.
"It was as if a small piece of his heart crumbled away with every step she took, leaving it a shredded mess by the time she'd reached the top of the stairs and disappeared out of sight." Spencer and Toby immediately after the heartbreak that was 4x21. Oneshot.
"He's so well-adjusted and mellow, and his smiles are so genuine, that it just slips her mind." Flashes in the shared life of Spencer Hastings and Toby Cavanaugh.
"It felt like there was cement in her shoes, Spencer thought as she dragged her feet up the steps to the loft where her boyfriend resided." Season 5 speculation/wishful thinking. Oneshot.
"He had no way of knowing the self-doubt she'd carried these past few weeks, or how it had left her feeling more fragile and shaky than ever before. Yet, it was as if he sensed it." Spencer and Toby immediately after his return from London. Oneshot.
"It seemed only logical that now, when at times she was so lost in her own mind that she couldn't tell you her own name, he was the one that figured out how to bring her back." The summer after the girls' senior year, the unspeakable happens. For Spencer Hastings, life as she once knew it is over forever. AU as of 4x17.
"They'd already ploughed through the difficult part. They'd reached the other side, miraculously still hand in hand, and now there was nothing left for him to do but hold her while they both processed." Set during 4x12. Deleted scenes, if you will. Oneshot.
"It still caught her off guard sometimes. No, that was a lie. It still caught her off guard all the time." Oneshot set in the future: Spencer and Toby in their early twenties.
"Arguments happened, fights occurred… it didn't mean you didn't care. On the contrary, really. Sometimes, especially with Toby, she got the feeling it happened because they cared too much." Post 4x16. Oneshot.