It has been a year since the events of FNaF: The Fourth Closet. It is now summer, and Charlie has returned from St. Louis, going to Hurricane where she will meet with her friends. Everything seems well, until she is informed by John that a new Freddy's-like location has opened in a neighboring town. This location looks faithful, however, it is hiding a dark secret.

What if Charlie had survived the climax of Five Nights at Freddy's: The Fourth Closet? In this alternate future, Charlie and the others team up to solve one last mystery.