Dawn moved to Santa Carla a few months ago. She never really felt like she belonged anywhere until she met her best friend, Brenda. One night, Brenda drags Dawn to a concert on the beach. A concert that would change Dawn's life forever.

A new student named Evelyn Hartley, whose part fairy part witch, comes to the Salvatore school. She doesn't know the extent of her power, but the school seems like a place she can truly belong to. Yet, a week after arriving, Malivore returns, which brings a whole new set of problems. What does he want? And how far will he go to get it? (Starts near the beginning of season 4)

Carly's life gets turned upside down by a vampire attack. She loses her friends, her family, and everyone she ever loved. Sam and Dean save Carly from joining her loved ones fate, but was she worth it? Sam can see the pain in her heart that she buries deep. Can he help her overcome that or will they both sink deeper, especially when they learn she isn't fully human herself?