Kara tried to tell Lena her secret at the Pulitzer party, but couldn't. The next day she reminisces over her old suit, forgetting that she and Lena had lunch plans. That leads to Lena finding out that she is Supergirl. That leaves Kara scrambling to fix the mistake of keeping her identity a secret from her best friend. However, both share a secret. Will they come to light?

Sunset Shimmer believes that equestrian magic is under control. However, that is far from true. Some of that magic finds its way to her gaming console. As a result, it brings out some familiar faces of the Five Nights at Freddy's games. Will Sunset and the girls be able to defeat the robotic nuisances? Or will they suffer the same fate as the night guards before them?