Kiara James is a 17-year-old girl who has only been living in Mystic Falls for the past couple of years. She managed to go unnoticed by the supernatural creatures in town until one night, she runs into Elijah Mikaelson. He finds himself inexplicably drawn to her but quickly realizes that, like most people in this town, she isn't what she seems.

Clarissa Teal is a profiler for the FBI and is recognized by the public as a "psychic detective". She is asked by name to consult with the team on a case and is quickly taken to Dr. Spencer Reid who can't seem to figure her out. Can the team deal with Clarissa's strange methods? Is Spencer and Clarissa going to become part of the statistic that suggest opposites do in fact attract?