Juvia and Magnus have each opened a portal in their own world. Natsu and Lucy get caught up in the magic and end up in Manhattan where they meet the New York Shadowhunters and all their friends. Lucy and Natsu have to get home, but how can they do that when they don't even know how they got there in the first place?

A different take on how Natsu and Lucy meet. Natsu has caused too damage! Makarov has stepped in and made Natsu take a job where there is no chance to cause damage. Natsu isn't looking forward to playing body guard for a rich girl, but just how will this job play out? Slight Nalu!