Amongst the stifling fumes and pervasive odors deep within the dungeons' Potions classroom, recent rumors circulating throughout Hogwarts about their hero's unlikely source of intrigue spark shocking revelations between one cynical professor and a certain green-eyed student. The ensuing conversation is retold - for authenticity's sake - with only the dialogue exchanged.

An alternate ending to Jack's initiation ceremony in regards to what might have happened if, in an act of guilt, he had followed Pitch's trail of destruction as the horses dragged him down.