In 1998 John sent a 19-year-old Dean to North Dakota to investigate a rash of cattle disappearances. What was supposed to be a simple recon and report quickly becomes more complicated when the disappearances escalate to humans. Outside perspective; told from the viewpoint of an OC hunter.

Dean Winchester is back from Hell, but the world is not as he left it. Plagued with conflicting memories he must struggle to unravel the mystery of how he is back, and why his past and present seemed to be following seperate scripts. Has he finally gone crazy, or is he the only one left sane?