Dawn knows it was supposed to be her. Set shortly after 5.22 "The Gift."

Willow has her regrets, especially about her relationships. Willow/Oz, Willow/Tara, Willow/Kennedy. Post-season eight. (Could be read as AU post-"Chosen.")

Willow screws up a spell. Buffy's wigged. Spike's ready to take full advantage. Spuffy. Early season six-ish.

For just a heartbeat, she doesn't quite expect his skin to be cold. Bangel. 1.19 "Sanctuary."

Out of all of them, she was the only one they didn't expect. Short post-NFA. Gen.

Tara's the one person Buffy felt most comfortable confiding in and her death doesn't change that. Some Spuffy and Tillow. Set between 7.04 "Help" and 7.05 "Selfless."

Spike finally shares some of his poetry with Buffy. Post-series. Spuffy.

After the battle against Wolfram and Hart, Spike and Angel find themselves alone, but not alone enough. Post-NFA.

Giles goes through with the truth spell and the gang asks Spike some pressing questions. Just not ones about the Initiative. During a slightly altered 4.09 "Something Blue."

Willow's Valentine's Day experiences have varied greatly through the years. Willow/Oz Willow/Tara Willow/Kennedy Willow/Aluwyn

The cavemen came out of the ground. The astronauts come out of the sky. A few hours after "Not Fade Away."

Buffy faces another outfit ruined by messy demon goo. Set during season two.

The day after Spike declares his love for her is Valentine's Day, and Buffy is not looking forward to what he might do to celebrate. Set the day after 5.14 "Crush."

Buffy never wanted to be like other Slayers, but she did want to be like other girls. Saffy (and past Buffy/other canon ships). Set during 8.12 "Wolves at the Gate, Part One."

Buffy gets ready to head back home after swooping in to help save LA and discovers that saying goodbye hasn't gotten easier yet. Bangel. Post-NFA.

Sometimes it's like Buffy's the only one who takes this whole apocalypse thing seriously. Post-series.

It doesn't take long at all for Buffy to regret her attempts at drowning her sorrows. Set during 6.05 "Life Serial."

Buffy isn't just going to let Illyria take what she wants. Not without a fight. Post-NFA. Spuffy.

Buffy's entrance into the underworld ends up being a bit less epic than she'd intended. Set at some point after 8.05 "The Chain."

After everything they've been through, it's getting harder for Angel to imagine Buffy still loving him. Set during early season nine/season one of Angel and Faith. Bangel.